Heterodox Economics Newsletter 298
20.06.2022
In recent weeks I received several calls from journalists asking whether a wage-price spiral is to be expected as a consequence of recent price hikes and whether we need interest rate hikes to combat increasing inflation. These questions are somewhat awkward as they still follow a more or less neoliberal economic policy script, which indicates that free-market economic policy is alive and well and that we learn much too little and too slow from the failures of capitalism – like financial crises, soaring inequality or ecological destruction. Also, it is difficult to say which of these two questions is more misguided: a price-wage spiral seems rather improbable given that (a) inflation emerges from hard short- to medium-run scarcities in raw materials and foodstuffs as well as misalignments in global value chains, and (b) bargaining power of workers is at a long-time low. Against this backdrop, assuming that labor costs are the decisive variable for understanding inflationary pressure seems somewhat off-the-wall to me as scarce labor is surely not the bottleneck in this equation. Rather, we observe that profits are soaring in tightening sectors – especially energy – which points to the fact that lack of competition contributes to rising prices, which should put the culprit on the side of capital, not labor.
In a similar vein, developed economies are not overheating in the traditional sense – rather they struggle to keep their established modes of provisioning that rely on (cheap) imports of raw materials and intermediate goods up and running under current circumstances. Again, this will not be resolved by pushing up interest rates, which will increase unemployment and maybe come with some dampening effect on the development of real estate prices. But it won't much affect relevant consumer prices in the short run given that the deeper reasons for the current inflationary pressures are to be found in the Corona pandemic and the war in Ukraine (see here for a fuller exposition of this topic). Reflecting on this topic also indicates that Putin is not such a bad economist as some may have hoped. He most probably understands these dependencies of Western provisioning systems on an extractive imperialism quite well as he currently profits from both rising prices for fossil energy as well as the strategic option to reduce exports to Europe as a means for exerting geopolitical power. Many western economists, who were so enthusiastic about our ability to cut off Russia from international financial markets, seemingly did not anticipate that. This probably because they are used to thinking in terms of 'gross-substitutability', i.e. the idea that scarce inputs will be quickly replaced by a cheaper alternative, which effectively amounts to ignoring existing technological constraints. This is nice for modeling purposes, but less apt for understanding actual production processes. Putin's simple assumption – that much production starts with some primary input that is often difficult to substitute – seems more on the point here, especially in the short- or medium-run.
While it is quite unclear how our global economic system will further evolve from this point, it seems evident to me that we are witnessing a turning point in our economic history: although the idea of an ever-increasing global integration of value chains and provisioning systems might not have fallen out of fashion ideologically, its practical implementation will be much more constrained by geopolitical realities and relationships in the near future. And some parts of the world – Europe especially – will have to reinvent themselves as they are forced to fundamentally rethink their strategies for production and provisioning on a large scale. In my view, being forced to reinvent ourselves is not the worst thing to happen.This could help to bring Europe closer together politically and, more importantly, could serve as a compelling reason to push sustainable structures of production and provisioning, e.g. by more forcefully expanding the production of renewable energy or by engaging in a large-scale restructuring of European traffic systems.
In my humble view, reacting to the unprecedent circumstances we currently observe will require a type of economic thinking that is (a) striving for realism, (b) willing and able to account for changing socio-economic contexts, (c) accurately assessing the heterogeneity of different production processes, and (d) concerned about inclusivity, provisioning for basic needs and an appreciation for the heterogenous impact economic crises have on different individuals and social groups. If I am roughly right on this, we currently observe a historical opportunity for heterodox economics to set some things right. And although our efforts might be too little and come too late, we should, as always, aim to do our best on this!
All the best & keep up the good work!
Jakob
© public domain
Table of contents
-
Call for Papers
-
11th Conference of the Iberian Association of the History of Economic Thought (Barcelona, Dec. 2022)
-
28th Annual Conference of the EuroMemo Group (London, Sept. 2022)
-
Forum for Social Economics: Symposium on "Social Reproduction and Biopolitics" (Online, August 2022)
-
International Conference: Power and Knowledge from the 18th Century to Today (France, November 2022)
-
Review of Political Economy: Special Issue on "Supermultiplier and Endogenous Money"
-
Ukrainian Association of International Economics: Conference on “Transition processes in Ukraine after the Russian-Ukrainian war: interdisciplinary evaluations” (hybrid, Nov. 2022)
-
Call for Participants
-
24th ESHET Summer School in History of Economic Thought (Strasbourg, August-September 2022)
-
2nd Modern Money Theory Summer School (Poznan, Aug. 2022)
-
9th International Research Conference on Social Economy (Seoul, July 2023)
-
CPERN mid-term workshop: "Critical Political Economy for a new Global Political Economy" (Limerick, July 2022)
-
Graz Schumpeter: Nancy Cartwright on "Economics, queen of the social sciences?" (Graz, Nov 22)
-
MMT 2nd Summer School (Poznań, August 2022)
-
Summer School on Agent-Based Stock-Flow Consistent (AB-SFC) modelling (Ancona, Sept. 2022)
-
Conference Papers, Reports, and Podcasts
-
Recordings from the Second Workshop of Structuralist Development Macroeconomics Research Group (SDMRG)
-
Job Postings
-
EDHEC-Risk Climate Impact Institute, France
-
Austrian Academy of Science, Austria
-
Europa-University Flensburg, Germany
-
King's College, UK (1/2)
-
King's College, UK (2/2)
-
Open University, UK
-
The College of New Jersey, US
-
University of Greenwich, UK
-
University of Porto, Portugal
-
University of Warsaw, Poland
-
Awards
-
Call for Submissions: E-axes Forum awards
-
Call for Submissions: GAIA Masters Student Paper Award 2023
-
Journals
-
Contributions to Political Economy 41 (1)
-
Ecological Economics 199
-
Feminist Economics 28 (2)
-
Industrial and Corporate Change 31 (3)
-
Journal of Post Keynesian Economics 45 (2)
-
Journal of the History of Economic Thought 44 (2)
-
Metroeconomica 73 (3)
-
New Political Economy 27 (4)
-
Rethinking Marxism 34 (2)
-
Review of Keynesian Economics 10 (2)
-
Science and Society 86 (2)
-
Books and Book Series
-
Digital, Class, Work: Before and During COVID-19
-
A Monetary and Fiscal History of Latin America, 1960–2017
-
A Revolutionary for Our Time: The Walter Rodney Story
-
Abolitionist Socialist Feminism: Radicalizing the Next Revolution
-
Boom and Bust: A Global History of Financial Bubbles
-
Bread and Beauty: The Cultural Politics of José Carlos Mariátegui
-
Digital, Class, Work: Before and During COVID-19
-
Economic Well-Being: An Introduction
-
How to Blow Up a Pipeline: Learning to Fight in a World on Fire
-
Microeconomía heterodoxa: Modelos sraffianos y marxistas
-
Sir Robert Geffrye and the Business of Slavery
-
The Austrian Revolution
-
The Mismeasure of Progress: Economic Growth and Its Critics
-
Heterodox Graduate Programs, Scholarships and Grants
-
New Master's in History of Economic Thought at University of Lyon
-
PhD studentship at The Open University Business School
|
Вхід для Членів
|